Explore Outer Banks's Paranormal History
Haunted Outer Banks
Why North Carolina's Outer Banks are considered one of the most haunted stretches of the American coast: shipwrecks, a vanished colony, pirates, and ghost ships.
The Outer Banks are a thin chain of barrier islands between the North Carolina mainland and the open Atlantic. For more than four centuries, their waters have claimed ships, their sands have hidden mysteries, and their history has produced some of America's most enduring legends. Here is why so many people believe these islands are haunted.
Why Are the Outer Banks So Haunted?
Discover the dark history and supernatural forces that make Outer Banks one of America's most haunted cities
The Outer Banks owe much of their haunted reputation to the sea around them. Shifting sands, constantly changing inlets, and the Diamond Shoals that stretch out from Cape Hatteras have made these waters some of the most dangerous on the Atlantic coast. Mariners came to call them the Graveyard of the Atlantic, and by one widely cited estimate, more than 5,000 ships have sunk here since 1526. The wrecks range from colonial sailing vessels to the Union ironclad USS Monitor, lost off Cape Hatteras in December 1862, and Blackbeard's flagship Queen Anne's Revenge, lost in 1718.
Every one of those wrecks carried people, and many never reached shore. During World War II, German U-boats hunted the merchant ships that passed along this coast, picking off vessels silhouetted against the lights on shore, and the waters off the Outer Banks became known as Torpedo Alley. Local legends tell of drowned sailors seen walking out of the surf during storms, of phantom ships glimpsed in the fog, and of cries carried on the wind from the shoals. Older tales tell of "wreckers" who allegedly lured ships aground at Nags Head by tying lanterns to horses and walking them along the dunes, so that captains mistook the bobbing lights for ships safely at anchor.
The islands are also home to America's oldest unsolved mystery. In 1585, an English expedition under Ralph Lane established a military outpost on Roanoke Island, but it was evacuated the following year. In 1587, John White led a second colony of approximately 115 men, women, and children to Roanoke. On August 18, 1587, a baby named Virginia Dare was born in the colony. White sailed back to England for supplies, and when he finally reached Roanoke in August 1590, the settlement was abandoned. The only clues were the word "CROATOAN" carved into a palisade post and the letters "CRO" carved into a tree. The colonists were never seen again.
More than four centuries later, the fate of the Lost Colony is still debated, and the site is preserved as Fort Raleigh National Historic Site, administered by the National Park Service since 1941. It is not hard to see why the mystery has inspired so many ghost stories. Visitors to Roanoke Island tell of figures in old-fashioned clothing among the trees, and local folklore has long told that Virginia Dare herself lives on in spirit, sometimes in the form of a white doe said to roam the island's woods.
Then there is Blackbeard. Edward Teach, the most notorious pirate of his age, knew these waters well, and they are where his story ended. On November 22, 1718, sailors under Lieutenant Robert Maynard, sent by Virginia Governor Alexander Spotswood, cornered Teach at Ocracoke Inlet. In the brutal fight that followed, Teach was killed; Maynard later found that he had been shot five times and cut about twenty times. His body was thrown into the inlet, and his head was hung from the bowsprit of Maynard's sloop as proof of his death.
Blackbeard's ghost has been part of Outer Banks folklore ever since. Some tell of "Teach's light," a strange glow seen on the water around Ocracoke at night. Others say his spirit still roams in search of his missing head. Ocracoke locals have long pointed to the waters where he fell, and stories of the pirate's restless ghost have been passed down for generations.
The sea has delivered its own mysteries, too. On January 31, 1921, a Coast Guard surfman spotted the schooner Carroll A. Deering hard aground on Diamond Shoals with all of her sails set. When investigators finally boarded her, the ship was empty. Her crew, her log, navigation equipment, personal effects, and two lifeboats were gone, and food appeared to have been in preparation in the galley. Five federal departments investigated, considering everything from hurricanes and piracy to rum-running and mutiny, but the inquiry closed without an official finding. The Deering is still remembered as one of the great ghost ships of the Atlantic coast.
Another vanishing has haunted these islands for more than two centuries. On December 31, 1812, Theodosia Burr Alston, the daughter of former Vice President Aaron Burr and the wife of South Carolina's governor, sailed from Georgetown, South Carolina, aboard the schooner Patriot, bound for New York. The ship was never seen again. Historians generally believe it was lost in a storm off Cape Hatteras, but Outer Banks legend tells a different story, involving wreckers and pirates. A portrait of a young woman acquired in 1869, known as the Nag's Head Portrait, was claimed to be Theodosia herself, though her relatives could not confirm it. The painting is now held at Yale's Lewis Walpole Library, and local lore says Theodosia's spirit still walks the beaches where she may have been lost.
Watching over it all stands Cape Hatteras Light. The present tower was completed in 1870 and first lit in December 1871, and at nearly 200 feet it is the tallest brick lighthouse in the United States. In 1999, with erosion having left it only about 15 feet from the water, the entire lighthouse was moved 2,900 feet inland. For generations, its beam has swept across the same waters that claimed so many ships and so many lives. Stand on the beach beneath it on a stormy night, with the wind coming off the Diamond Shoals, and it is easy to understand why the Outer Banks have collected so many ghost stories.
5,000+
Ships Sunk in the Graveyard of the Atlantic Since 1526
1587
Lost Colony Settles Roanoke Island
1718
Blackbeard Killed at Ocracoke Inlet
Outer Banks's Haunted Places: Coming Soon
We're writing up the story of each of Outer Banks's haunted places. Until then, the best way to meet them is on one of our ghost tours.
Ready to Explore Outer Banks's Dark Side?
Don't miss out on the #1 rated ghost tour experience in Outer Banks. Book your adventure today!
Why Book With Ghost City Tours?
Multiple Tour Options
Choose from family-friendly, adults-only, or pub crawl experiences.
Top-Rated Experience
From the world's #1 ghost tour company.
Tours 7 Days a Week
Rain or shine, we run tours every single night of the year.
Money-Back Guarantee
Love your tour or get a full refund - that's our promise!
Tours Sell Out Daily
Outer Banks is a popular destination. Book now to guarantee your spot!
Book Your Ghost Tour Today
Book Online Now
SAVE TIME- Choose from all available tour times
- Instant email confirmation
- Secure, encrypted checkout
- 100% Money Back Guarantee
Prefer to Call?
Our Guest Services team is available 7 days a week to help you book the perfect tour.
CALL 855-999-04917am - 11:30pm Daily